Assessment criteria
After submitting your CDS model, the jury will start assessing your submission. The criteria that the jury will assess are presented below. The maximum amount of points is 12.
| Criteria name | Criteria description | Maximum amount of points |
|---|---|---|
| Clinical relevance | Your CDS application shall be based on international, European or Swedish national/regional clinical practice guidelines. | 1 point (where 0.5 points are given for European and Swedish national/regional guidelines and an additional 0.5 for international guidelines) |
| Clinical impact | Clinical impact determines how the algorithms will impact how much of a population. | 1 point |
| Quality on clinical models description | When creating your clinical models, you need to add meta-data as described in the tutorials. Clarity and correctness of the meta-data is important when creating a CDS application. | 1 point |
| Language | English and Swedish are a prerequisite. However, we encourage additional languages. Additional languages can give up to an extra half point. | 1.5 points (correct English and Swedish gives 1 point and additional languages can give up to 0.5 points) |
| Quality on clinical modelling of the CDS application | Models must adhere to standards such as openEHR archetypes or HL7 FHIR, and may incorporate relevant terminologies. They must have a clear, well-organized structure and logical flow to ensure they are easily understood.
Additionally, we encourage reuse of existing archetypes and guidelines as the building blocks of your CDS application. | 2 points (where 0.5 of these points are for good reusability of existing archetypes and another 0.5 for good reusability of existing guidelines). |
| UX design of the CDS application | Your application has a good, unique and intuitive UX design. Furthermore more complex and responsive UX can give more points. | 1.5 points (where 0.5 are for a good UX design and up to 1 additional point for more complex and responsive UX) |
| Correctness of CDS application logic | Your CDS application and models shall perform calculations and other logic correctly. | 2 points (1 point for GDL2 guidelines logic and 1 point for Form logic) |
| Test coverage of the guideline logic | In the Guideline Editor, there is one tab for creating tests for your guideline. We require at least 3 test cases. (See tutorials for more information). | 1 point |
| Complexity of the CDS application | CDS applications vary in their complexity, a CDS application with a higher complexity level will be provided with more points. | 1 point |
